The hotel is new and old, your experience could depend on which part of the hotel your room is in. Having visited this Hotel last year. You see the reception area A1 the pool and bar / breakfast area A1. So when this hotel came up as available with the great location. It was on our short list. When you arrive it takes me back to Skiathos in the 1980's . We have been to Skiathos maybe 18-22 times in the last nearly 30 years.
We can live with the ants in the bathroom, the two sings which you find it hard to have a good shave because the plugs don't work ( mechanical plugs ), we can live with the bath not shower curtain, water splashes about a bit, the old days of the hole in the floor water would drain away, here you was left with a wet floor. we can live with the one wall light and two lamp shades, the third plug in light didn't work, when I tried to swap the lamp to another area the socket was loose from the wall, it is Greece.
The newer rooms had nice looking garden furniture to sit on, ours had horrible old very old wicker chairs, but it's Greece. Breakfast could have saved the day it didn't, I could go on, even the cooked style breakfast was cold at the 8am opening or go for a later breakfast still cold
Would I go again not to this hotel. Maybe if you get a better room your review maybe better.
We will be back to Skiathos later this year again